| N.L. EAST | |
| Arizona Diamondbacks | Jordan Lawler - shortstop |
| Cincinnati Reds | Elly De La Cruz - shortstop |
| San Francisco Giants | Patrick Bailey - catcher |
| Texas Rangers | Evan Carter - outfielder |
| Washington Nationals | Jake Irvin - starting pitcher |
| N.L. Central | |
| Colorado Rockies | Brenton Doyle - outfielder |
| Milwaukee Brewers | Sal Frelick - outfielder |
| Minnesota Twins | Edouard Julien - 2nd base |
| Philadelphia Phillies | Johan Rojas - outfielder |
| St. Louis Cardinals | Jordan Walker - outfielder |
| N.L. West | |
| Chicago Cubs | Peter Crow-Armstrong - outfielder |
| Houston Astros | Corey Julks - outfielder |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | Bobby Miller - starting pitcher |
| Miami Marlins | Eury Perez - starting pitcher |
| New York Mets | Kodai Senga - starting pitcher |
| A.L. East | |
| Baltimore Orioles | Grayson Rodriguez - starting pitcher |
| Boston Red Sox | Masataka Yoshida - outfielder |
| Cleveland Guardians | Tanner Bibee - starting pitcher |
| New York Yankees | Anthony Volpe - shortstop |
| Toronto Blue Jays | Davis Schneider - 2nd base |
| A.L. Central | |
| Atlanta Braves | A.J. Smith-Shawver - starting pitcher |
| Tampa Bay Rays | Junior Caminero - 3rd base |
| Chicago White Sox | supplemental pick |
| Detroit Tigers | Parker Meadows - outfielder |
| San Diego Padres | Steven Wilson - relief pitcher |
| A.L. West | |
| Kansas City Royals | Freddy Fermin - catcher |
| Los Angeles Angels | Zach Neto - shortstop |
| Oakland Athletics | Zack Gelof - 2nd base |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | Endy Rodriguez - catcher |
| Seattle Mariners | Bryce Miller - starting pitcher |