| 2023 American League | 2023 National League | |
| C - Adley Rutschman - Orioles | C - Travis d'Arnaud - Phillies | |
| 1B - Vlad Guerrero Jr - Blue Jays | 1B - Pete Alonso - Mets | |
| 2B - Jose Altuve - Blue Jays | 2B - Jorge Polanco - Phillies | |
| SS - Xander Bogaerts - Royals | SS - Carlos Correa - Astros | |
| 3B - Manny Machado - Orioles | 3B - Nolan Arenado - Dodgers | |
| CF - Julio Rodriguez - Mariners | CF - George Springer - Astros | |
| OF - Aaron Judge - Yankees | OF - Oscar Gonzalez - Rockies | |
| OF - Mike Trout - Mariners | OF - Yordan Alvarez - Astros | |
| DH - Jose Abreu - White Sox | DH - Freddie Freeman - Twins | |
| 2022 American League | 2022 National League | |
| C - Salvador Perez - Mariners | C - Omar Narvaez - Rangers | |
| 1B - Vlad Guerrero Jr. - Blue Jays | 1B - Josh Bell - Rangers | |
| 2B - Gleyber Torres - White Sox | 2B - Jonathan Schoop - Astros | |
| SS - Tim Anderson - White Sox | SS - Javier Baez - Rangers | |
| 3B - Rafael Devers - Royals | 3B - Nolan Arenado - Dodgers | |
| CF - Myles Straw - Orioles | CF - Akil Baddoo - Rockies | |
| OF - A.J. Pollock - Red Sox | OF - Mitch Haniger - Reds | |
| OF - Michael Brantley - Mariners | OF - Yordan Alvarez - Astros | |
| DH - Shohei Ohtani - Angels | ||
| 2021 American League | 2021 National League | |
| C - Salvador Perez - Mariners | C - J.T. Realmuto - Brewers | |
| 1B - Jose Abreu - White Sox | 1B - Eric Hosmer - Royals | |
| 2B - D.J. LeMahieu - Mariners | 2B - Robinson Cano - Reds | |
| SS - Tim Anderson - White Sox | SS - Trea Turner - Nationals | |
| 3B - Manny Machado - Orioles | 3B - Willi Castro - Twins | |
| CF - Teoscar Hernandez - Blue Jays | CF - George Springer - Astros | |
| OF - Kyle Tucker - White Sox | OF - Marcel Ozuna - Phillies | |
| OF - Lourdes Gurriel Jr. - A's | OF - Juan Soto - Nationals | |
| DH - Mike Trout - Mariners | DH - Wil Myers - Astros | |
| 2020 American League | 2020 National League | |
| C - Wilson Ramos - Royals | C - Omar Narvaez - Rangers | |
| 1B - Freddie Freeman - Braves | 1B - Josh Bell - Rangers | |
| 2B - DJ LeMahieu - Mariners | 2B - Keston Hiura - Brewers | |
| SS - Xander Bogaerts - Royals | SS - Trevor Story - Rockies | |
| 3B - Josh Donaldson - Pirates | 3B - Anthony Rendon - Nationals | |
| CF - Ketel Marte - Mariners | CF - George Springer - Astros | |
| OF - Mike Trout - Mariners | OF - Christian Yelich - Rangers | |
| OF - Ronald Acuna Rr - Braves | OF - Yordan Alvarez - Astros | |
| DH - Nelson Cruz - Rays | ||
| 2019 American League | 2019 National League | |
| C - Wilson Ramos - Royals | C - Jorge Alfaro - Phillies | |
| 1B - Edwin Encanacion - White Sox | 1B - Rhys Hoskins - Phillies | |
| 2B - Jose Altuve - Blue Jays | 2B - Scooter Gennett - Brewers | |
| SS - Xander Bogaerts - Royals | SS - Trevor Story - Rockies | |
| 3B - Manny Machado - Orioles | 3B - Alex Bregman - Astros | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - Joey Gallo - Rangers | |
| OF - Ronald Acuna Jr - Braves | OF - Christian Yelich - Rangers | |
| OF - Eddie Rosario - Angels | OF - David Peralta - Reds | |
| DH - Khris Davis - Mariners | ||
| 2018 American League | 2018 National League | |
| C - Gary Sanchez - Braves | C- Evan Gattis - Twins | |
| 1B - Jose Abreu - White Sox | 1B - Joey Votto - Reds | |
| 2B - Jose Altuve - Blue Jays | 2B - Scooter Gennett - Brewers | |
| SS - Didi Gregorius - Blue Jays | SS - Carlos Correa - Astros | |
| 3B - Jose Ramirez - Angels | 3B - Miguel Sano - Twins | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - George Springer - Astros | |
| OF - Aaron Judge - Yankees | OF - J.D. Martinez - Cardinals | |
| OF - Eddie Rosario - Angels | OF Marcell Ozuna - Phillies | |
| DH - Justin Smoak - Angels | ||
| 2017 American League | 2017 National League | |
| C - Salvador Perez - Mariners | C - Yadier Molina - Cardinals | |
| 1B - Freddie Freeman - Braves | 1B - Joey Votto - Reds | |
| 2B - Ian Kinsler - White Sox | 2B - Cesar Hernandez - Phillies | |
| SS - Tim Anderson - White Sox | SS - Trevor Story - Rockies | |
| 3B - Kyle Seager - Mariners | 3B - Adrian Beltre - Reds | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - Christian Yelich - Rangers | |
| OF - Charlie Blackmon - Padres | OF - J.D. Martinez - Cardinals | |
| OF - Starling Marte - Pirates | OF - Mookie Betts - Royals | |
| DH - Mark Trumbo - Orioles | ||
| 2016 American League | 2016 National League | |
| 1B - Adrian Gonzalez - Padres | 1B - Chris Davis - Phillies | |
| 2B - Ian Kinsler - White Sox | 2B - Dee Gordon - Mets | |
| SS - Adeiny Hechavarria - Royals | SS - Carlos Correa - Astros | |
| 3B - Manny Machado - Orioles | 3B - Miguel Sano - Twins | |
| C - Buster Posey - Giants | C - Stephen Vogt - Mets | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - Randal Grichuk - Cardinals | |
| OF - Nick Markakis - Orioles | OF - David Peralta - Twins | |
| OF - Andrew McCutchen - Mariners | OF - Christian Yelich - Rangers | |
| DH - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | ||
| 2015 - missing | 2015 - missing | |
| 2014 American League | 2014 National League | |
| 1B - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | 1B - Chris Davis - Phillies | |
| 2B - Jose Altuve - Blue Jays | 2B - Ian Kinsler - Rangers | |
| SS - Jimmy Rollins - Mariners | SS - Jed Lowrie - Pirates | |
| 3B - Kyle Seager - Mariners | 3B - Adrian Beltre - Reds | |
| C - Jarrod Saltalamachia - Blue Jays | C - Jason Castro - Astros | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - Coco Crisp - Phillies | |
| OF - Andrew McCutchen - Mariners | OF - Matt Holliday - Phillies | |
| OF - Jose Bautista - Royals | OF - Michael Cuddyer - Rangers | |
| DH - David Ortiz - Padres | ||
| 2013 American League | 2013 National League | |
| 1B - Adrian Gonzalez - Padres | 1B - Prince Fielder - Brewers | |
| 2B - Howie Kendrick - Tigers | 2B - Aaron Hill - Rays | |
| SS - Hanley Ramirez - D-Backs | SS - Ian Desmond - Nationals | |
| 3B - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | 3B - Adrian Beltre - Reds | |
| C - Carlos Ruiz - Cubs | C - Buster Posey - Giants | |
| CF - Mike Trout - Mariners | CF - Matt Kemp - Rangers | |
| OF - Andrew McCutchen - Mariners | OF - Ryan Braun - Brewers | |
| OF - Nori Aoki - Cubs | OF - Josh Hamilton - Reds | |
| DH - David Ortiz - Padres | ||
| 2012 American League | 2012 National League | |
| 1B - Adrian Gonzalez - Padres | 1B - Prince Fielder - Brewers | |
| 2B - Rickie Weeks - Cubs | 2B - Daniel Murphy - Dodgers | |
| SS - Starlin Castro - Cubs | SS - Troy Tulowitzki - Rockies | |
| 3B - Chipper Jones - Padres | 3B - Adrian Beltre - Reds | |
| C - Mike Napoli - Blue Jays | C - Yadier Molina - Cardinals | |
| CF - Andrew McCutchen - Angels | CF - Matt Kemp - Rangers | |
| OF - Coco Crisp - Cubs | OF - Ryan Braun - Brewers | |
| OF - Alfonso Soriano - Tigers | OF - Melky Cabrera - Dodgers | |
| DH - David Ortiz - Padres | ||
| 2011 American League | 2011 National League | |
| 1B - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | 1B - Albert Pujols - Cardinals | |
| 2B - Neil Walker - Mariners | 2B - Rickie Weeks - Twins | |
| SS - Rafael Furcal - Braves | SS - Troy Tulowitski - Rockies | |
| 3B - Casey McGehee - Braves | 3B - Evan Longoria - Rays | |
| C - A.J. Pierzynski - Angels | C - Joe Mauer - Twins | |
| CF - Dextor Fowler - Braves | CF - Josh Hamilton - Reds | |
| OF - Nelson Cruz - Royals | OF - Matt Holliday - Rockies | |
| OF - Shin-Soo Choo - Yankees | OF - Jose Bautista - Giants | |
| DH - Travis Hafner - Yankees | ||
| 2010 American League | 2010 National League | |
| 1B - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | 1B - Albert Pujols - Cardinals | |
| 2B - Aaron Hill - D-Backs | 2B - Ian Kinsler - Rangers | |
| SS - Hanley Ramirez - Red Sox | SS - Troy Tulowitski - Rockies | |
| 3B - Chipper Jones - Padres | 3B - Aramis Ramirez - Brewers | |
| C - Matt Wieters - Orioles | C - Joe Mauer - Twins | |
| CF - Adam Jones - Orioles | CF - Torii Hunter - Twins | |
| OF - Jason Kubel - Braves | OF - J.D. Drew - Cardinals | |
| OF - Josh Willingham - Blue Jays | OF - Ryan Braun - Brewers | |
| DH - Adam Lind - Blue Jays | ||
| 2009 American League | 2009 National League | |
| 1B - Ryan Howard - Red Sox | 1B - Mark Teixeira - Rangers | |
| 2B - Aaron Miles - Red Sox | 2B - Ian Kinsler - Rangers | |
| SS - Mike Aviles - Royals | SS - Cristian Guzman - Cardinals | |
| 3B - Alex Rodriguez - Mariners | 3B - Evan Longoria - Rays | |
| C - Geovanny Soto - White Sox | C - Joe Mauer - Twins | |
| CF - Jody Gerut - Angels | CF - Josh Hamilton - Reds | |
| OF - Carlos Quentin - Yankees | OF - Andre Ethier - Reds | |
| OF - Curtis Granderson - Tigers | OF - Milton Bradley - Dodgers | |
| DH - David Ortiz - Yankees | ||
| 2008 American League | 2008 National League | |
| 1B - Todd Helton - Mariners | 1B - Carlos Pena - Rays | |
| 2B - Jeff Kent - Giants | 2B - Chase Utley - Phillies | |
| SS - Jimmy Rollins - Mariners | SS - Miguel Tejada - Phillies | |
| 3B - Alex Rodriguez - Mariners | 3B - Adrian Beltre - Pirates | |
| C - Ben Molina - Royals | C - Russell Martin - Dodgers | |
| OF - Barry Bonds - Giants | OF - Adam Dunn - Reds | |
| OF - Carlos Beltran - Mariners | OF - Matt Holliday - Rockies | |
| OF - Alfonzo Soriano - Angels | OF - Hunter Pence - Astros | |
| DH - Jim Thome - Giants | P - Micah Owings - Rays | |
| 2007 American League | 2007 National League | |
| 1B - David Ortiz - Braves | 1B - Albert Pujols - Cardinals | |
| 2B - Robinson Cano - Yankees | 2B - Ray Durham - Astros | |
| SS - Rafael Furcal - Braves | SS - Miguel Tejada - Phillies | |
| 3B - Chipper Jones - Cubs | 3B - Scott Rolen - Phillies | |
| C - Ramon Hernandez - Cubs | C - Joe Mauer - Twins | |
| OF - Barry Bonds - Giants | OF - Matt Holliday - Rockies | |
| OF - Lance Berkman - Angels | OF - Mosies Alou - Devil Rays | |
| OF - Magglio Ordonez - White Sox | OF - Vladimir Guerrero - Nationals | |
| DH - Travis Hafner - Royals | ||
| 2006 American League | 2006 National League | |
| 1B - Lyle Overby - Blue Jays | 1B - Derrek Lee - Reds | |
| 2B - Jeff Kent - Giants | 2B - Adam Kennedy - Marlins | |
| SS - Derek Jeter - Blue Jays | SS - David Eckstein - Dodgers | |
| 3B - Miguel Cabrera - Royals | 3B - Aramis Ramirez - Brewers | |
| C - Rod Barajas - Angels | C - Jason Varitek - Astros | |
| OF - Andruw Jones - Braves | OF - Jason Bay - Pirates | |
| OF - Lance Berkman - Angels | OF - Carl Crawford - Devil Rays | |
| OF - Jim Edmonds - Giants | OF - Geoff Jenkins - Marlins | |
| DH - David Ortiz - Braves | ||
| 2005 - missing | 2005 - missing | |
| 2004 - missing | 2004 - missing | |
| 2003 - missing | 2003 - missing | |
| 2002 AL - missing | 2002 National League | |
| 1B - Jason Giambi - Reds | ||
| 2B - Brett Boone - Pirates | ||
| SS - Rich Aurilia - Twins | ||
| 3B - Chipper Jones - Bbraves | ||
| C - Paul LoDuca - Cardinals | ||
| CF - Juan Pierre - Rockies | ||
| OF - Barry Bonds - Dodgers | ||
| OF - Larry Walker - Expos | ||
| 2001 American League | 2001 National League | |
| 1B - Carlos Delgado - A's | 1B - Jason Giambi - Reds | |
| 2B - Luis Castillo - Tigers | 2B - Jeff Kent - Twins | |
| SS - Alex Rodriguez - Mariners | SS - Barry Larkin - Reds | |
| 3B - Troy Glaus - Blue Jays | 3B - Chipper Jones - Braves | |
| C - Ivan Rodriguez - Rangers | C - Charles Johnson - Marlins | |
| CF - Darrin Erstad - Orioles | CF - Richard Hildago - Astros | |
| OF - David Justice - Blue Jays | OF - Barry Bonds - Dodgers | |
| OF - Sammy Sosa - Angels | OF - Manny Ramirez - Padres | |
| DH - Edgar Martinez - Tigers | ||
| Silver Slugger Award started in 2001 |